How To Remove Bike CVrank Without Crank Puller

Removing a bike crank is a common task for cyclists who perform their own maintenance. While a crank puller is the standard tool for this job, sometimes you find yourself without one, and you still need to get the crank off. Whether you’re doing this at home or on the trail, knowing alternative methods is essential for keeping your bike in top shape.

To remove a bike crank without a crank puller, you can use basic tools like a rubber mallet, a pry bar, or even penetrating oil to loosen stubborn parts. While it may seem tricky, with the right technique, you can safely remove the crank without damaging your bike. Always proceed with caution, and ensure you’re applying force evenly to avoid harming the frame or bottom bracket.

Performing your own bike repairs, especially without all the specialized tools, is a satisfying experience that builds your cycling knowledge. Having the skill to remove a crank without a puller not only saves you time and money but also gives you confidence when you’re far from a bike shop. With a bit of patience and the right approach, it’s a task that every rider can handle.

Contents show

Tools You’ll Need

When you don’t have a crank puller handy, using alternative tools is your best bet. While they may not be specialized, common tools can work just as well if used correctly. Here’s what you’ll need:

Alternative Tools

Rubber mallet: A rubber mallet helps apply force without damaging your bike. It’s a useful tool for gently knocking the crank loose.
Flathead screwdriver: This is ideal for prying the crank away from the bottom bracket, but be gentle to avoid scratches.

Penetrating oil: If the crank is stuck, penetrating oil will help loosen rust or debris between the parts.
Pry bar: A small pry bar can be used carefully to create leverage and remove the crank.
Hex keys (Allen wrenches): You’ll need these to remove the crank bolts.

Safety Equipment

Gloves: Wearing gloves will protect your hands from sharp edges and provide a better grip.
Protective eyewear: Small parts can fly off when force is applied, so it’s important to protect your eyes.
Bike stand (if available): A bike stand makes it easier to work, keeping the bike stable and at a comfortable height.

Old rag or towel: Keep one handy for cleaning the crank and bottom bracket once removed.

Preparing Your Bike

Before you begin removing the crank, it’s important to prepare your bike properly. This preparation ensures that the process goes smoothly and prevents damage.

Steps to Prepare the Bike

Secure the bike: If you have a bike stand, use it to hold the bike upright and stable. If you don’t have one, lean the bike against a wall or flip it upside down, resting it on the handlebars and seat. Securing the bike prevents it from moving while you work.

Remove the pedals: Loosen the pedals before working on the crank. Use a pedal wrench to unscrew each pedal from the crank arms. Removing the pedals gives you better access to the crank, making the process easier.
Clean the crank area: Wipe down the crank and surrounding area with a rag or towel. This removes dirt, oil, or rust that might interfere with the process.

Importance of Securing the Bike

Securing the bike is one of the most important steps. A loose or wobbly bike can make the task harder and potentially lead to injury. When the bike is secure, you can focus on removing the crank without worrying about the bike tipping over or moving around. This is especially crucial when using tools that require both hands, like a mallet or pry bar.

Loosening the Pedals for Better Access

Loosening or removing the pedals is a simple but effective way to make crank removal easier. Pedals can get in the way, especially when you’re using tools like a mallet or pry bar. Removing them opens up more space for you to work, ensuring that you can approach the crank from any angle.

Loosening the Crank Bolts

With the bike prepped, the next step is to loosen the crank bolts. These bolts hold the crank arms in place and must be removed before attempting to take off the crank.

Step-by-Step Guide to Loosening Crank Bolts

Identify the crank bolts: Crank bolts are typically located at the center of each crank arm. They are usually hex bolts and require a hex key (Allen wrench) to remove.

Choose the right hex key: Use the appropriate size hex key, usually 8mm, to fit the bolts snugly.
Turn counterclockwise: Insert the hex key into the bolt and turn it counterclockwise to loosen. It may take some effort at first, especially if the bolt is tight.
Remove the bolts: Once loosened, completely unscrew the bolts and set them aside in a safe place.

Tips for Dealing with Stubborn or Rusted Bolts

Apply penetrating oil: If the bolts are rusted or stuck, apply a few drops of penetrating oil to loosen them up. Wait a few minutes before attempting to loosen them again.
Use a breaker bar: If a standard hex key doesn’t give you enough leverage, try attaching a breaker bar to increase the torque.
Tap lightly with a hammer: Gently tapping the bolt with a hammer can help loosen rust or debris that may be holding it in place.

Using a Rubber Mallet or Hammer

Once the crank bolts are removed, it’s time to dislodge the crank from the bottom bracket. This is where a rubber mallet or hammer comes in handy. Using a mallet allows you to apply force without causing damage.

How to Use a Rubber Mallet

Position the mallet: Place the rubber mallet against the crank arm, near the bottom bracket, where it connects to the spindle.
Tap gently: Start by tapping the mallet lightly against the crank arm. This loosens the connection between the crank and the bottom bracket.

Increase force if needed: If the crank doesn’t budge after a few gentle taps, increase the force slightly. Be cautious not to hit too hard, as this could damage the spindle or crank.
Alternate sides: Tap on both sides of the crank arm to apply even pressure and prevent it from getting stuck.

Safety Precautions When Using a Mallet or Hammer

Avoid hitting too hard: While it might be tempting to use more force, hitting the crank too hard can cause serious damage. It’s better to apply moderate, controlled force.

Protect the bike frame: Make sure the rubber mallet is soft enough to avoid scratching or denting the frame. If you’re using a hammer instead, place a soft rag or towel between the hammer and the bike to prevent damage.
Secure the bike: Always make sure the bike is secured in place before using any tool, especially a hammer or mallet. A stable bike prevents accidental slips or damage.

The Pry Bar or Screwdriver Technique

If you don’t have a crank puller, a pry bar or flathead screwdriver can help you remove the crank. While this method isn’t as precise as using a crank puller, it’s effective when done with care.

Instructions for Using a Pry Bar or Screwdriver

Position the bike securely: Make sure the bike is stable, using a stand or leaning it against a wall.
Insert the tool: Carefully slide the pry bar or flathead screwdriver between the crank arm and the bottom bracket. The goal is to create just enough space to pry the crank off the spindle.
Apply gentle force: Push down on the tool gently to avoid damaging the bike’s frame. It’s important to apply even pressure to prevent bending or scratching the crank or frame.

Work both sides: Move to the other side of the crank and repeat the process. This ensures that the crank is loosened evenly, reducing the risk of it getting stuck.
Check for movement: Once the crank starts to move, you’re making progress. If the crank is still firmly in place, move to the next step of applying penetrating oil for assistance.

Emphasis on Gentle Force

Using a pry bar or screwdriver requires patience. Applying too much force too quickly can damage your bike. A key factor here is even pressure—make sure that you’re working from both sides and keeping the tool at a consistent angle to avoid damaging the crank or the bike frame.

Applying Penetrating Oil

Penetrating oil can be your best friend when a crank is stuck. It’s specifically designed to loosen rust, debris, or any other material causing parts to stick together. It’s essential to use the right oil for bike parts to avoid damaging components like rubber seals.

How Penetrating Oil Helps

Penetrating oil seeps into the small gaps between the crank and the spindle. This loosens any rust, dirt, or debris that might be causing the crank to stick. The longer you let the oil sit, the more effective it becomes. This method is especially useful if the bike has been exposed to wet or dirty conditions over time.

Step-by-Step Guide for Applying Penetrating Oil

Spray the oil: Apply a small amount of penetrating oil to the area where the crank arm meets the spindle. Be sure to aim directly at the gap where the two parts connect.

Wait for the oil to work: Let the oil sit for 5 to 10 minutes. This gives it time to penetrate the stuck areas and loosen the debris or rust. In some cases, you might need to wait a little longer.
Check for looseness: After waiting, try to gently wiggle the crank. If it’s still stuck, apply a bit more oil and wait another few minutes.
Use the mallet again: After the oil has set, gently tap the crank with your rubber mallet to help loosen it further. The combination of the oil and light tapping usually helps free up the crank.

Removing the Crank by Hand

Once the crank is loosened enough, you can remove it by hand. This is the easiest part of the process, but you should make sure that it’s truly ready to come off to avoid damage.

When and How to Remove the Crank by Hand

Check for wiggle: After loosening the crank bolts, applying penetrating oil, and using a mallet, check if the crank moves freely. If it wiggles, it’s ready to be removed by hand.
Pull the crank off: Grab the crank arm and gently pull it away from the bottom bracket spindle. Use steady, even pressure to avoid bending or damaging any parts.

Use both hands: If the crank is still a little stiff, use both hands to work the crank off. Pull it straight out to ensure you don’t damage the spindle or crank arm.

Common Signs the Crank is Loose Enough

The crank wiggles easily when you apply slight pressure.
You’ve removed all the bolts, and the crank moves when tapped with a mallet.

After using penetrating oil, the crank slides off with little effort.

Troubleshooting Common Issues

Sometimes, removing a crank doesn’t go as smoothly as planned. Here are some common issues and how to solve them.

Crank Still Stuck

If the crank remains stuck even after applying oil and tapping it with a mallet, try the following:

Apply more oil: Another dose of penetrating oil can help. Wait a little longer for it to soak in.
Use a different angle: Adjust the position of your pry bar or screwdriver and try to dislodge the crank from a different angle.
Tap harder: Gently increase the force of your taps with the mallet. Just be careful not to overdo it.

Rusted or Damaged Bolts

Rusted bolts can be a real headache, especially if they’ve been exposed to wet conditions over time. Here’s how to tackle the issue:

Use penetrating oil: Just like with the crank, penetrating oil can help loosen rusted bolts. Apply it directly to the bolt and let it sit for a few minutes.
Try a bolt extractor: If the bolt is stripped or damaged, a bolt extractor tool can remove it.

Damaged Crank

If you notice any damage to the crank, it’s best to stop and assess the situation. Continuing with a damaged crank can cause further harm to your bike. In some cases, you might need to replace the crank entirely.

Reinstalling the Crank

Once you’ve removed the crank and completed any necessary maintenance, you’ll need to reinstall it. While reinstalling doesn’t require a crank puller, proper alignment and torque are essential to make sure everything fits snugly and operates smoothly.

Steps for Reinstalling the Crank

Clean the spindle: Before reinstalling the crank, make sure the spindle is clean and free of any debris or dirt. Use a rag to wipe down the area.

Align the crank: Line up the crank arm with the spindle. Make sure it’s properly aligned, as misalignment can affect your ride and potentially damage the bike.
Hand-tighten the crank bolts: Start by hand-tightening the crank bolts to ensure everything is in the right position.
Tighten with a hex key: Use your hex key to fully tighten the crank bolts. Be careful not to over-tighten, but make sure the crank is secure.

Check for proper torque: If you have a torque wrench, use it to check that the crank bolts are tightened to the manufacturer’s recommended specifications. This ensures the crank won’t come loose during a ride.

Importance of Proper Alignment and Torque

When reinstalling the crank, proper alignment ensures a smooth and safe ride. If the crank is not aligned correctly, it can cause wobbling or unnecessary wear on your bike components. Torque is equally important—over-tightening can strip the bolts, while under-tightening can lead to the crank coming loose during a ride.

FAQs

Can I remove a bike crank without a puller?

Yes, it is possible to remove a bike crank without a puller using alternative tools. You can loosen the crank bolts and use a rubber mallet, pry bar, or penetrating oil to help dislodge the crank. Be mindful of the force you apply to avoid damaging the crank or bike frame.

What tools do I need to remove a crank without a crank puller?

You will need a few common tools such as a rubber mallet, flathead screwdriver or pry bar, and penetrating oil. These can serve as alternatives to a crank puller, but you should proceed with care to avoid damaging the bike components.

Will removing the crank without a puller damage my bike?

If done correctly, removing the crank without a puller won’t damage your bike. However, using too much force or the wrong technique can cause damage to the bottom bracket, crank arms, or bike frame. It’s important to take your time and apply even, controlled force.

How do I know if the crank is ready to be removed by hand?

After loosening the crank bolts and applying some force with a rubber mallet or pry bar, the crank should begin to loosen. If it wiggles slightly or you feel it give way, it may be loose enough to remove by hand. Always check that all bolts are fully loosened before attempting to pull it off.

Conclusion

Removing a bike crank without a crank puller can be a challenge, but it’s a task that can be managed with patience and the right tools. Whether you’re using a rubber mallet or a pry bar, ensuring you apply even force and proceed carefully will help prevent damage to your bike. This method is a great way to handle repairs when you don’t have all the necessary equipment on hand.

Learning how to perform these types of DIY repairs not only enhances your cycling experience but also gives you the confidence to handle unexpected issues while out on the trail. With a little practice, you’ll be able to maintain your bike in top shape, ensuring smoother rides and a longer lifespan for your gear.